Heart of Darkness versus Slumdog Millionaire

For the past month or so, my English Criticism class has been constantly been getting sidetracked and have talked in great length about Slumdog Millionaire instead of the assigned reading. Today, having failed to read the assigned essay about Heart of Darkness, I was not allowed to voice my opinion on the book and whether or not the author is racist. However, when we transitioned in to Slumdog, the instructor it seems has many opinions about the film. The film that she has not seen.

My question is: Do I point out that she is commenting on a film that she has not seen?

8 Responses to “Heart of Darkness versus Slumdog Millionaire”

  1. Jamie S. Rich Says:

    Hell yes! I hated when profs pulled shit like that.

  2. Lisa Says:

    Absolutely point it out. I hate when people voice opinions about movies they've not seen.

    And then read the rest of Heart of Darkness!

  3. chartroose Says:

    Maybe you should compare/contrast Conrad with Slumdog. There was a lot of racism in both of them!

  4. The Book Pirate Says:

    I sent her an e-mail asking if Slumdog would somehow be related to the final.

  5. Lisa Says:

    Absolutely point it out. I hate when people voice opinions about movies they've not seen.

    And then read the rest of Heart of Darkness!

  6. chartroose Says:

    Maybe you should compare/contrast Conrad with Slumdog. There was a lot of racism in both of them!

  7. The Book Pirate Says:

    I sent her an e-mail asking if Slumdog would somehow be related to the final.

  8. car valuation Says:

    Tumblr article…

    I saw someone writing about this on Tumblr and it linked to…

General Stuff
Since January 2008 I have been using this blog to write about the books i've read and other book related news that I find interesting. I also find pirates interesting so from time to time I may blog about pirates. I see this as killing two birds with one stone.

Review Policy
Dear Publishers/Authors,

I am always willing to discuss reviewing you book on my blog. Discovering new authors is one of the things I love about book blogging. However, I do not accept all books for review. If it's not in my usual genre chances are I am going to decline the offer.

A couple of genres I dislike are: Self-Help, YA Paranormal, Hardcore Science-Fiction, and Depressing Memoirs.

Some genres I really enjoy: Pirates, Satire, Pulp Fiction, Queer Fiction, YA Fiction (Non-Paranormal and Non-Gossip Girl-esq) and Comical Memoirs.

Here's the thing. If you e-mail me asking me to review a book, I will always respond and let you know if I am interested or not. If you don't hear back from me, feel free to send a follow-up e-mail. No longer will I just ignore your e-mail.

-Colin Matthew
Contact Me

Search