The Book Pirate’s Musings on… Midnight Sun
I mention Wednesday about an incomplete draft of Stephenie Meyer’s Midnight Sun being leaked on to the internet and how she was so distraught that she placed the book on “infinite hold” which is often a euphemism for “canceled”. Well, I’ve had more time to think about it and I have a couple more thoughts on the subject.
First off, was it really worth it to “infinitively hold” a book just because part of it was leaked? This seems like punishing everyone for a mistake that only one person made. Last time I check the Twilight Saga had sold over 50 million copies worldwide. By “infinitively holding” the book, Meyer has essentially bitch slapped 50 million readers right across the face.
This brings me to the readers, the fans, the people who have started comparing Stephenie Meyer to the likes of J.K. Rowling and who will be lining up to see the midnight showing of the movie based of the first book in the Twilight Saga. These readers have stuck with her for four books and made Meyer popular. I’m dumbfounded as to how an author could just ignore her fan base. Imagine if you will that prior to Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince’s release someone reveled that Dumbledore died. Would J.K. stand up and say “Alright, it’s been spoiled. There is no need for me to release any more Harry Potter books.” There would be riots I imagine and a state of martial law would have to be enforced until things calmed down.
“But wait,” you, the reader, say. “Isn’t it her right as an author, no as an artist, to control her art as she sees fit?” Good point. To answer your question, yes. As a writer I feel that I have complete control over what I write, how I write, and when I write. Naturally, I am unpublished so the world of deadlines and editors is not something I am dealing with right now. Meyer can do whatever she wants to in her story. She is the author, she has the control.
But consider this, would you watch a movie with the last fifteen minutes missing? How would you feel if went in to the film not knowing that the ending was removed? Would you read a novel that had the last chapters removed? That is how I feel about the decision to cancel Midnight Sun.
To my understanding, the four currently released Twilight books complete the main story arch and the fifth and final book, Midnight Sun, was to be through the perspective of another character. I can’t say for sure if Midnight Sun does constitute additional content for the main story of the Twilight Saga. But something apparently struck with Meyer and she, at one point, felt compelled to write an entire book that would compliment the previous four. Writing a book is no easy task yet to canceling it seemed to be rather simple.
Meyer is viewing the leak of her book as a bad thing while I view it as something that could help make Midnight Sun an awesome book. Writers tend to show their drafts to a handful of people who give feed. I enjoy receiving feedback and welcome all of it. What Meyer has is the opportunity to collect vast amounts of feedback from fans who are engrossed in the world of Twilight. Who better to help make the book be the best it could be? From what I’ve gathered from people who read the latest book, Breaking Dawn, it wasn’t as good as the three previous books. One of my friends said that it felt like it was written by an entirely different person. Midnight Sun is a chance to end the Twilight Saga on a high note and go out with a bang.
Either way, I wont be losing sleep over the fact that I may never get to read Midnight Sun. What I am upset about is Stephenie Meyer’s attitude towards the leak and how she feels that she must punish her entire fan base because of it.